Difference between revisions of "Team:OUC-China/Demonstrate"

Line 234: Line 234:
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
<div class="zhiqi" style="display:inline-block;width:100%;vertical-align: top;text-align:center;">
 
<div class="zhiqi" style="display:inline-block;width:100%;vertical-align: top;text-align:center;">
<div class='text'>Inspiration</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>1. Introduction</div></br>
<div class='text'>We are still like the Wright Brothers, putting pieces of wood and paper together.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Our project this year focuses on a standardized design principle to be used for modular and  tunable riboswitch, which can easily be applied by future teams. We looked at the exsiting riboswitch, where current negative issues like context dependent performance, limited response curve and hard to toggle the on-off state would be addressed as well as solved within our project. The solution to these fundamental but complex issues was introducing Stabilizer, Tuner and asRNA to construct and regulate modular riboswitch, also named RiboLego.</div></br>
<div class='text'>——Luis Serrano</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>The modular riboswitch we defined consists of the original riboswitch, Stabilizer and Tuner. Stabilizer can protect the structure of riboswitch from damage while Tuner can reduce the expression probability of fusion protein and make improvement of riboswitch function. We test our design principle in different riboswitches including three kinetic switches: Adda riboswitch, Btub riboswitch, cobalamin biosensor, and one thermodynamic switch: FourU riboswitch. What's more, three different kinds of GOI is used including sfGFP, YFP, and mRFP1. The good results show the high universality of our design principles. We believe that we have fulfilled this medal requirement because we can show our system working under real world conditions.</div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>By snapping together various pieces of different colors, shapes and sizes from a Lego box, a multitude of structures with different functions such as a boat, a car, and a building can be readily built. In the ideal world of synthetic biology, biological parts such as genes, promoters, and terminators are analogously treated as Lego blocks. </div></br>
+
<div class='text'>2. Normally express the gene </div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>First, we successfully demonstrated that Stabilizer restored the normal function of riboswitch while Tuner tackled this problem of inclusion body generated by Stabilizer. By fluorescence microscopy, we can clearly observe that Tuner is capable of making GOI express normally. </div></br>
 +
<div class='text'></div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Figure 1: The fluorescence images represent situation when fluorescence excitation by confocal microscopy. The images show E.coli with 2-AP. Compared with the original Adda riboswitch system and Adda fusion construct, an obvious fluorescence can be observed in modular Adda riboswitch system.</div></br>
 +
<div class='text'></div></br>
 +
<div class='text'></div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Figure 2: The fluorescence images represent situation when fluorescence excitation by confocal microscopy. The images show E.coli with VB12. Compared with the original Btub riboswitch system and Btub fusion construct, an obvious fluorescence can be observed in modular Btub riboswitch system.</div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>However, the key challenges in synthetic biology in real life exist on two main levels. One is the modularization and standardization of biological parts, while the other is the integration of these biological parts into devices with desired functions. Unlike Lego blocks, many of the existing parts are still incompatible and unpredictable, whose variability will crash the syst1em sometimes. </div></br>
 
<div class='text'>So biologic parts of “Lego-ization” are necessary.</div></br>
 
 
<div class='text'> </div></br>
 
<div class='text'> </div></br>
<div class='text'>Since their discovery, riboswitches have been attractive tools in bacterial systems. Natural riboswitches are found with the highest frequency in the 5’-UTR of bacterial mRNAs, they have two main components: an “aptamer domain” and an “expression platform”. in response to the binding of a specific target molecule, they can regulate the expression of downstream genes through structural changes. Also, more artificial riboswitches are engineered to regulate the expression of proteins of interest. </div></br>
 
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>The useful application of riboswitch</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>3. Amplify the riboswitch function</div></br>
<div class='text'>①Metabolism and behavioural regulation</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Before starting the wet lab work, the core idea of Tuner was successfully modeled by a thermodynamic approach. Using a series of Tuner constructs, we then expand the response curve of modular riboswitch. Five different Tuners were introduced downstream of the activating Adda riboswitch and Stabilizer. Tuners were able to shift the system’s induction response to 2-aminopurine in a manner that correlated with the strength of Tuner.</div></br>
<div class='text'>Directing mobility of bacteria to specific locations using theophylline in a ligand‐dependent manner.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>②Screening for traits</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Lysine riboswitch control antibiotic resistance to screen for Escherichia coli strains with higher lysine fermentation efficiency.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>③Regulation of genes</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Use Aminoglycoside riboswitch to increase bacteria resistance to antibiotics.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>④Production of compounds</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>RNAT (temperature response) can rapid response to temperature for the production of compounds without the use of costly ligands.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>⑤Biosensor</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Flavonoid riboswitch can detect the flavonoid contamination.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>⑥Bioremediation</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>ykkC riboswitch is able to respond to the environmental toxin guanidine to break it down.</div></br>
+
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Figure 3: Histograms show the relative fluorescence expression of sfGFP by microplate reader. Response of each modular Adda riboswitch to 0, 8, 32 and 250 μM 2-aminopurine as compared to the fusion construct(Adda-STA-sfGFP). The five test groups present different fluorescence intensities from high to low, which proves that Tuners have different capabilities. Error bars represent standard deviation of three biological replicates.  </div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>We collaborated with four teams which helped us prove the results of Tuner A by experiments in their labs. </div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Figure 4: The results from other four teams which proved our conclusions. Histograms show the relative fluorescence expression of sfGFP by microplate reader. Response of modular Adda riboswitch including Tuner A to 0, 8, 32 and 250 μM 2-aminopurine. Error bars represent standard deviation of three biological replicates.  </div></br>
 +
<div class='text'> </div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>To demonstrate the universal applicability of our design principle, the repressing Btub riboswitch was employed that binds adenosylcobalamin. In order to reduce the metabolic burden of cells,we created Tuner H consisting of SsrA degradation tag, which could degrade Stabilizer. Using Tuner A, E and H, we were successfully able to show that we could in fact change the function of riboswitch.</div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Figure 5: The fluorescence intensity of sfGFP by microplate reader during the entire cultivation period. By using three different Tuners, we could change the response curve of Btub riboswitch. Error bars represent standard deviation of four biological replicates.  </div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>But due to context-dependent performance and limited dynamic range, the use of riboswitches is often restricted. </div></br>
+
<div class='text'>We also tested our system working by replacing sfGFP with YFP which were introduced downstream of the activating Adda riboswitch, Stabilizer and Tuner A.</div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Figure 6:  The result by microplate reader. The emission of YFP was measured at a wavelength of 527nm when excited at 514nm. Error bars represent standard deviation of three biological replicates. Data was selected  when steady state is reached (at least two consecutive subsequent data points do not increase fluorescence).</div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>Non-plug and play device Hard to control its response function Impossible to reset its state</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>4. Select the appropriate length of Stabilizer</div></br>
<div class='text'>Team Paris_Bettencourt  has used a riboswitch whose ligand is vitamin B12 to measure the concentration of vitamin B12 in foods. They directly added eGFP after the riboswitch but found that no eGFP expression at all. After that, although eGFP was substituted with mRFP1 and natural truncated protein was inserted between mRFP1 and the riboswitch, they finally observed a bad result. We guess that the structure of riboswitch has been changed. Natural riboswitches primarily serve as key autonomous regulators of diverse metabolic processes. However, the application of riboswitch was restricted by the low dynamic regulatory ranges and low tunability. To effectively regulate genes with riboswitch, an appropriate strategy must be employed to tune the response curve, achieving the multi output by responsing to single input. Because small molecules are often hard to degrade in the experimental culture system, it often causes some problems and makes the system away from prediction. 2018 Team William and Mary  also focused on this problem. By talking with Prof. Wang,  we found the kinetic switch could not easily toggle between the on and off state, which results in some logic functions is lost.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Guided by math modeling, we determined that the Stablilizer length of Adda and Btub was 150bp. Furthermore, we would prove the effectiveness of our software. So we selected 9bp and 21bp as bad Stabilizers but 81bp and 129bp as good Stabilizers for Adda. The results showed that the length of Stabilizer was changable.</div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>All in all, the three problems above make the riboswitch quite hard to design and employ to the application, which make it can’t be regarded as a modular device. Towards to the three problems, now the exiting strategies are describing following by:</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Figure 7: The fluorescence intensity of sfGFP by microplate reader during the entire cultivation period. By using four different Stabilizers, we could prove that our software was effective. 9bp and 21bp was too short that can stabilize the structure of Adda riboswitch, leading that the failure of responsive to ligand. </div></br>
<div class='text'> </div></br>
+
<div class='text'>~ To make the riboswitch as a modular plug-and-play device, scientists try to insert a sequence between the riboswitch and gene of interest to protect the structure of riboswitch from damage so that we can change the CDS easily.  The sequence they have chosen is by random design and test by some high-throughput screening method such as SELEX. </div></br>
+
<div class='text'> </div></br>
+
<div class='text'>~ To change the response functions of riboswitch, scientists try to design the expression platform by biology method and rational design. Many studies used the directed evolution  to optimization the dynamics range of specific riboswitch and develop the bio-physics model  to design it.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'> </div></br>
+
<div class='text'>~To change the concentration of ligand in the experimental culture system, scientists often use the physics-based method, such as microfluidics device  or replacing the media with fresh non-inducer-containing media .</div></br>
+
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>By reviewing the exiting problem and solutions towards them, we are aware of some aspects worth optimizing. Adding a redundant sequence before the GOI directly will lead to the expression of fusion protein which may destroy the GOI's structure and function. And the method such as random design and directed evolution may waste too much time to achieve the goal you desired . While the effect of the microfluidics device is various between different labs. </div></br>
+
<div class='text'>5. Improvement</div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Using our design principle of modular riboswtch, we were successfully able to improve the  cobalamin biosensor created by Paris_Bettencourt team in 2015. They used a riboswitch whose ligand is vitamin B12 to express mRFP1 without its start codon and inserted the first 30bp of the natural gene between them. By confocal microscopy, no fluorescence was be observed because the length of Stabilizer was too short that destroy the structure of riboswitch. By introducing Stabilizer and Tuner A, we constructed an improved cobalamin riboswitch, which can restore his function and express mRFP1 normally. </div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>This year, OUC-China proposed a standardized design principle named “RiboLego” which can break the deadlock we have mentioned before, making the riboswitch a modular, tunable one and easy to toggle between the on and off state. We hope our design will make it easier and more efficient for future igem teams to get the expected expression by using riboswitch .</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Figure 8: The results by confocal microscopy, which indicates that our principle can improve cobalamin biosensor successfully. It's obvious that the modular cobalamin riboswitch can express mRFP1.</div></br>
<div class='text'></div></br>
+
<div class='text'>We divide modular riboswitch into three parts: the original riboswitch, Stabilizer, Tuner from 5' to 3'. </div></br>
+
<div class='text'> </div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Stabilizer is a sequence which can prevent the structure of the riboswitch from damage. It has a clear source to generate and the appropriate length designed by model.</div></br>
+
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>Tuner placed between Stabilizer and the GOI to split them from each other has a function that reduces the expression probability of fusion protein and avoids destroying the GOI's structure and function. What's more, designed by model, Tuner can be used to control the riboswitch function precisely, achieving the desired level of expression.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>Figure 9: The fluorescence intensity of mRFP1 by microplate reader during the entire cultivation period. We measured part BBa_K1678007 designed by Paris_Bettencourt in 2015 and the improved circuit designed by us. As shown that, by introducing Tuner A, modular cobalamin biosensor was capable of expressing mRFP1 normally in response to different concentrations of VB12. </div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>We validate our design principle in different riboswitches including three kinetic switches: Adda riboswitch, Btub riboswitch, cobalamin biosensor, and one thermodynamic switch:  Four U riboswitch. What's more, three different kinds of GOI is used including sfGFP, YFP, and mRFP1. The good results show the high universality of our design principle.</div></br>
 
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>To toggle between the on and off state of kinetic switches, we use the model to design different asRNAs which target different region to activate or deactivate the riboswitch. We will optimize this system continuously and finally achieved to regulate the on-off state of riboswitch.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>6. The thermodynamic switch</div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Riboswitches can furthermore be classifified into thermodynamic and kinetic switches. We then explored whether our design principles apply to thermodynamic riboswitches. Using Four U, whose temperature threshold is 37℃, we can successfully express sfGFP in 37℃ and 42℃. In this circuit, the first 81bp of mRFP1 was selected as Stabilizer because Four U can control the expression of mRFP1 normally and Tuner A was used. The result shows Tuner can be applied to the thermodynamic riboswitches perfectly!</div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Figure 10:The results of microplate reader show the working effect of modular Four U element in different temperature.</div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>7. Control the on-off state in real time </div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>By above results, we have demonstrated that Tuners are able to overcome many of the issues preventing widespread use of riboswitches. After constructing modular riboswitches, we have successfully designed antisense RNA to achieve our goals of controling the on-off state in real time. The good results demonstrated our effective approach.</div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>Figure 11: The heat map generated from microplate reader data reflecting the change of fluorescence intensities with and without IPTG. Using our IPTG inducible antisense RNA, we could control the on-off state of Adda and Btub riboswitch.</div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>All in all, inspired by the three existing blocks, we design our alternative riboswitch design frameworks, 'RiboLego', to make the riboswitch modular, tunable, reliable and time-saving.</div></br>
+
<div class='text'>8. Summary</div></br>
 +
<div class='text'>We believe that we have fulfilled this medal requirement because we have successfully demonstrated that our design principle could expand riboswitch function. Our system could  work under realistic conditions. Please see our other pages for more inspiration and results. Additionally, see our medal requirements for information on how we fufilled our medal requirements.</div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
 
<div class='text'></div></br>
<div class='text'>Click here to get more information about our achievements!</div></br>
+
 
  
  

Revision as of 07:31, 21 October 2019

kkkkk




















































1. Introduction

Our project this year focuses on a standardized design principle to be used for modular and tunable riboswitch, which can easily be applied by future teams. We looked at the exsiting riboswitch, where current negative issues like context dependent performance, limited response curve and hard to toggle the on-off state would be addressed as well as solved within our project. The solution to these fundamental but complex issues was introducing Stabilizer, Tuner and asRNA to construct and regulate modular riboswitch, also named RiboLego.

The modular riboswitch we defined consists of the original riboswitch, Stabilizer and Tuner. Stabilizer can protect the structure of riboswitch from damage while Tuner can reduce the expression probability of fusion protein and make improvement of riboswitch function. We test our design principle in different riboswitches including three kinetic switches: Adda riboswitch, Btub riboswitch, cobalamin biosensor, and one thermodynamic switch: FourU riboswitch. What's more, three different kinds of GOI is used including sfGFP, YFP, and mRFP1. The good results show the high universality of our design principles. We believe that we have fulfilled this medal requirement because we can show our system working under real world conditions.


2. Normally express the gene

First, we successfully demonstrated that Stabilizer restored the normal function of riboswitch while Tuner tackled this problem of inclusion body generated by Stabilizer. By fluorescence microscopy, we can clearly observe that Tuner is capable of making GOI express normally.


Figure 1: The fluorescence images represent situation when fluorescence excitation by confocal microscopy. The images show E.coli with 2-AP. Compared with the original Adda riboswitch system and Adda fusion construct, an obvious fluorescence can be observed in modular Adda riboswitch system.



Figure 2: The fluorescence images represent situation when fluorescence excitation by confocal microscopy. The images show E.coli with VB12. Compared with the original Btub riboswitch system and Btub fusion construct, an obvious fluorescence can be observed in modular Btub riboswitch system.




3. Amplify the riboswitch function

Before starting the wet lab work, the core idea of Tuner was successfully modeled by a thermodynamic approach. Using a series of Tuner constructs, we then expand the response curve of modular riboswitch. Five different Tuners were introduced downstream of the activating Adda riboswitch and Stabilizer. Tuners were able to shift the system’s induction response to 2-aminopurine in a manner that correlated with the strength of Tuner.


Figure 3: Histograms show the relative fluorescence expression of sfGFP by microplate reader. Response of each modular Adda riboswitch to 0, 8, 32 and 250 μM 2-aminopurine as compared to the fusion construct(Adda-STA-sfGFP). The five test groups present different fluorescence intensities from high to low, which proves that Tuners have different capabilities. Error bars represent standard deviation of three biological replicates.


We collaborated with four teams which helped us prove the results of Tuner A by experiments in their labs.


Figure 4: The results from other four teams which proved our conclusions. Histograms show the relative fluorescence expression of sfGFP by microplate reader. Response of modular Adda riboswitch including Tuner A to 0, 8, 32 and 250 μM 2-aminopurine. Error bars represent standard deviation of three biological replicates.


To demonstrate the universal applicability of our design principle, the repressing Btub riboswitch was employed that binds adenosylcobalamin. In order to reduce the metabolic burden of cells,we created Tuner H consisting of SsrA degradation tag, which could degrade Stabilizer. Using Tuner A, E and H, we were successfully able to show that we could in fact change the function of riboswitch.


Figure 5: The fluorescence intensity of sfGFP by microplate reader during the entire cultivation period. By using three different Tuners, we could change the response curve of Btub riboswitch. Error bars represent standard deviation of four biological replicates.


We also tested our system working by replacing sfGFP with YFP which were introduced downstream of the activating Adda riboswitch, Stabilizer and Tuner A.

Figure 6: The result by microplate reader. The emission of YFP was measured at a wavelength of 527nm when excited at 514nm. Error bars represent standard deviation of three biological replicates. Data was selected when steady state is reached (at least two consecutive subsequent data points do not increase fluorescence).


4. Select the appropriate length of Stabilizer

Guided by math modeling, we determined that the Stablilizer length of Adda and Btub was 150bp. Furthermore, we would prove the effectiveness of our software. So we selected 9bp and 21bp as bad Stabilizers but 81bp and 129bp as good Stabilizers for Adda. The results showed that the length of Stabilizer was changable.


Figure 7: The fluorescence intensity of sfGFP by microplate reader during the entire cultivation period. By using four different Stabilizers, we could prove that our software was effective. 9bp and 21bp was too short that can stabilize the structure of Adda riboswitch, leading that the failure of responsive to ligand.


5. Improvement

Using our design principle of modular riboswtch, we were successfully able to improve the cobalamin biosensor created by Paris_Bettencourt team in 2015. They used a riboswitch whose ligand is vitamin B12 to express mRFP1 without its start codon and inserted the first 30bp of the natural gene between them. By confocal microscopy, no fluorescence was be observed because the length of Stabilizer was too short that destroy the structure of riboswitch. By introducing Stabilizer and Tuner A, we constructed an improved cobalamin riboswitch, which can restore his function and express mRFP1 normally.


Figure 8: The results by confocal microscopy, which indicates that our principle can improve cobalamin biosensor successfully. It's obvious that the modular cobalamin riboswitch can express mRFP1.


Figure 9: The fluorescence intensity of mRFP1 by microplate reader during the entire cultivation period. We measured part BBa_K1678007 designed by Paris_Bettencourt in 2015 and the improved circuit designed by us. As shown that, by introducing Tuner A, modular cobalamin biosensor was capable of expressing mRFP1 normally in response to different concentrations of VB12.



6. The thermodynamic switch

Riboswitches can furthermore be classifified into thermodynamic and kinetic switches. We then explored whether our design principles apply to thermodynamic riboswitches. Using Four U, whose temperature threshold is 37℃, we can successfully express sfGFP in 37℃ and 42℃. In this circuit, the first 81bp of mRFP1 was selected as Stabilizer because Four U can control the expression of mRFP1 normally and Tuner A was used. The result shows Tuner can be applied to the thermodynamic riboswitches perfectly!

Figure 10:The results of microplate reader show the working effect of modular Four U element in different temperature.


7. Control the on-off state in real time

By above results, we have demonstrated that Tuners are able to overcome many of the issues preventing widespread use of riboswitches. After constructing modular riboswitches, we have successfully designed antisense RNA to achieve our goals of controling the on-off state in real time. The good results demonstrated our effective approach.

Figure 11: The heat map generated from microplate reader data reflecting the change of fluorescence intensities with and without IPTG. Using our IPTG inducible antisense RNA, we could control the on-off state of Adda and Btub riboswitch.


8. Summary

We believe that we have fulfilled this medal requirement because we have successfully demonstrated that our design principle could expand riboswitch function. Our system could work under realistic conditions. Please see our other pages for more inspiration and results. Additionally, see our medal requirements for information on how we fufilled our medal requirements.