Difference between revisions of "Team:Marburg/Human Practices"

Line 713: Line 713:
 
                   breeding research, industry, ethics research and genetic engineering critics should give the public
 
                   breeding research, industry, ethics research and genetic engineering critics should give the public
 
                   an insight into the different breeding methods and the according viewpoints of different
 
                   an insight into the different breeding methods and the according viewpoints of different
                   stakeholders. After a keynote lecture by biochemist Prof. Dr. Lars-Oliver Essen from Philipps
+
                   stakeholders. After a keynote lecture by biochemist Prof. Dr. Lars-Oliver Essen from the Philipps-
                   University in Marburg the panel discussion started. It was moderated by Michael Lange of "Forschung
+
                   University of Marburg the panel discussion started. It was moderated by Michael Lange of "Forschung
 
                   aktuell" from Deutschlandfunk and team member Paula Mueller. The energetic audience, in which all
 
                   aktuell" from Deutschlandfunk and team member Paula Mueller. The energetic audience, in which all
 
                   age groups were represented, soon actively took part in the discussion, asked questions and
 
                   age groups were represented, soon actively took part in the discussion, asked questions and
Line 743: Line 743:
 
                   Most of the panelists agreed that genetic engineering offers opportunities, especially in
 
                   Most of the panelists agreed that genetic engineering offers opportunities, especially in
 
                   agriculture, to address challenges such as climate change or the nutrition of the growing world
 
                   agriculture, to address challenges such as climate change or the nutrition of the growing world
                   population. According to the introductory statement of Prof. Dr. Andreas Weber from the Plant
+
                   population. According to the introductory statement of Prof. Dr. Andreas Weber from the Cluster of Excellence on Plant
                   Science Excellence Cluster at Heinrich-Heine University in Düsseldorf, methods of genetic
+
                   Science at Heinrich-Heine University in Düsseldorf, methods of genetic
 
                   engineering such as CRISPR are already established tools and have no cause for concern, particularly
 
                   engineering such as CRISPR are already established tools and have no cause for concern, particularly
                   in basic research. But subsequently, modified organisms cannot be tested in the field under natural
+
                   in fundamental research. But subsequently, modified organisms cannot be tested in the field under natural
                   conditions. However, the objective testing and checking of modified plants is a problem, because
+
                   conditions. However, the objective of testing and checking modified plants is a problem, because
                   often independent testing organisations would not have access to certified seeds and the complete
+
                   often independent testing organisations do not have access to certified seeds and the complete
 
                   data used in the designing process, replied Dr. Christoph Then from testbiotech e.V.<br>
 
                   data used in the designing process, replied Dr. Christoph Then from testbiotech e.V.<br>
 
                   <br>
 
                   <br>
Line 755: Line 755:
 
                   established breeding methods, the product should be the basis of the review, argued Daniel
 
                   established breeding methods, the product should be the basis of the review, argued Daniel
 
                   Stukenberg, representative of the party "The Humanists". A point of view with a drastically
 
                   Stukenberg, representative of the party "The Humanists". A point of view with a drastically
                   different background, here represented by ethics professor Dr. Friedemann Voigt, put the consumer in
+
                   different background, here represented by ethics professor Dr. Friedemann Voigt, put the consumers in
                   the foreground and demanded its right to know how a food is produced. This led the discussion
+
                   the foreground and demanded their right to know how a food is produced. This led the discussion
                   further in the direction of the effects of genetically modified feed on farm animals and the human
+
                   further in the direction of the effects of genetically modified animal feed on farm animals and the human
 
                   consumer. At this point, Dr. Christoph Then criticised the sharp decline in risk research, which
 
                   consumer. At this point, Dr. Christoph Then criticised the sharp decline in risk research, which
 
                   pursues society's protective goals with regard to health.<br>
 
                   pursues society's protective goals with regard to health.<br>
 
                   <br>
 
                   <br>
                   The podium also separated into simple gene edited and transgenic organisms. While gene edited plants
+
                   The panel also separated into simple gene edited and transgenic organisms. While gene edited plants
 
                   do not contain genes from foreign organisms, such genes in transgenic plants can, for example,
 
                   do not contain genes from foreign organisms, such genes in transgenic plants can, for example,
 
                   provide certain ingredients that make them resistant to pests or insecticides/herbicides. Transgenic
 
                   provide certain ingredients that make them resistant to pests or insecticides/herbicides. Transgenic
Line 768: Line 768:
 
                   approval of the audience, which was expressed by strong applause. Transgenic plants could not
 
                   approval of the audience, which was expressed by strong applause. Transgenic plants could not
 
                   develop in a natural way and should therefore not be used in agriculture. At the moment, however,
 
                   develop in a natural way and should therefore not be used in agriculture. At the moment, however,
                   the use of genetically modified plants in organic farming is also not in compliance with the
+
                   the use of genetically modified plants in organic farming is also not in compliance with  
 
                   regulations, according to Freya Schäfer of FiBL (Research Institute of Organic Agriculture).<br>
 
                   regulations, according to Freya Schäfer of FiBL (Research Institute of Organic Agriculture).<br>
 
                   <br>
 
                   <br>
Line 777: Line 777:
 
                     alt="Placeholder image">
 
                     alt="Placeholder image">
 
                   <figcaption>
 
                   <figcaption>
                     Fig.2 - Recording of the panelists in the middle of arguing with the viewers.
+
                     Fig.2 - Recording of the panelists in the middle of arguing with the viewers. Members of the panel are (left to right): Paula Müller, Prof. Dr. Friedemann Voigt, Dr. Claus Kremoser, Daniel Stukenberg, Freya Schäfer, Dr. Christoph Then, Prof. Dr. Andreas Weber and Michael Lange.
 
                   </figcaption>
 
                   </figcaption>
 
                 </figure>
 
                 </figure>

Revision as of 13:04, 7 December 2019

H U M A N   P R A C T I C E S


Report on Genetic Engineering

Genetic engineering has been a hotly debated topic in politics as well as society in the past decades and still is today. Arguments like the nutrition of a growing world population due to a declining infant mortality rate or the loss of considerable areas of arable land due to erosion or pollution damage keep fueling the controversy whether genetically modified organisms (GMO), especially crops, are needed to sustain the global demand for food. On the opposite, concerns have been raised concerning the potential adverse effects on human health and environmental safety. Besides the facts, part of the public dispute is based around ethical questions and trust issues towards institutions and authorities. There have been studies and surveys carried out addressing many of these topics. Additionally a diverse cluster of organisations and the media is bombarding the public with contrary statements. This report tries to give an overview on mankind's relation towards modifying genetics, a brief summary of used methods, and gathers statements from scientists and authorities. It is meant as the motivational basis for this years Marburg iGEM team´s Public Engagement and Human Practice efforts.


G M O
R E P O R T


Gathering reviews, opinions and statements, this report is meant as the foundation of our Human Practice efforts.

D R .  N I N A
S C H E E R


Policy makers are caught between public concerns and expert opinions. Communication is key.

P L A N T   M A R K E T


Reaching out to senior people, we advertised our panel discussion and adressed public concerns towards genetically modified organims.

P A N E L D I S C U S S I O N


The panel discussion allowed regional residents to debate with experts from various fields about green genetic engineering.

Integrated Human Practices

C Y A N O
B I O T E C H


Influencing our project on many levels: growth curves, terminators and well plate cultivation.

P R O F.   D R.
A N N E G R E T   W I L D E


Cultivation expertise from leading cyano scientist Prof. Wilde.

D O U L I X


Confirmation for real case use for our colony picking project.

S T A N D A R D I Z A T I O N


Realizing that we are not the only ones struggeling with no cyano research standarization...

C Y A N O
C O N F E R E N C E   2 0 1 9


Knowledge exchange with established cyanobacteria researchers.

E X P E R T   O N   C Y A N O S :
J A M E S   G O L D E N


Defining the absent standardization to discrepancies in light, optical denisty measurement and more.

E X P E R T   O N   C Y A N O S:
N I C O L A S  S C H M E L L I N G


And soon, we could add growth media to the growing list of not existing standardization.

O P E N T R O N S
+   K E O N I


Initial inspirations for our colony picking project.

P R O M E G A


Automation of plasmid purification using the OT-2.